The Coming Storm1869
9 in. x 13 in. (22.86 cm x 33.02 cm)
The personal energy manifested by Bierstadt's movements spilled over into his work as a painter. He was, in a phrase, zestfully prolific. A journalist's appreciative remark of 1863 about Frederic Edwin Church, Bierstadt's contemporary and rival, that Church was so productive he seemed to be "painting with both hands,"1 more befitted Bierstadt. By the middle of the sixties Bierstadt often had two or three large works, as well as many medium-size and smaller pictures, under way at once. He kept to near that pace through the 1880s. Aptly coupled with his high studio output were his considerable social skills and his fondness for the limelight. Throughout the late 1850s and the 1860s he adroitly interacted with American and, subsequently, European journalists. During the 1870s and 1880s, when much of the American press and many of his colleagues were critical of him, he continued to seek out sympathetic reviewers, and he seldom if ever spurned those reporters who came to him. He and his works still attracted attention in some sectors of the New York print media as late as the mid-1890s. Hence, for more than three decades the completions and public releases of his paintings were often, so far as he was concerned, matters of timing as much as of creativity.
Yet despite his prolonged propensity for self-documentation and the high interest nowadays in his life and art,2 segments of Bierstadt's chronology and a consequential proportion of his oeuvre remain problematic. By the late 1860s, doubtless in recognition of slipping sales, he began not dating his studio paintings while continuing to sign most images that he touched. The destruction by fire in November 1882 of his country house, Malkasten, in Irvington, New York, doubtless consumed many business records as well as quantities of his sketches and studio works. After his death the surviving contents of his studio were dispersed at auctions and among the relatives of his first and second wives. In consequence, little is now known about his sketching procedures. The freewheeling, repetitious methods that facilitated his studio practice further complicate modern estimates of him.
The Addison Gallery's two small paintings by Bierstadt, both of fine quality, exemplify these historical uncertainties. The generic theme of The Snow Mountain—a sunlit summit surrounded by shadowed ridges, all glimpsed from an elevation—captivated the artist, as we know from his enthusiastic response to a Colorado mountain vista that opened suddenly before him in 1863.3 The size, materials, and paint handling of the present piece suggest a transcript taken at a specific site. But where? Given Bierstadt's many crossings of the Alps and the American West, one may ask if the particular view is—or is supposed to be—European or North American. A firm answer proves elusive, however. Recent attempts to identify the scene with the Jungfrau and/or the nearby valley of the Lauterbrunnen, both in Switzerland, and with Bierstadt's large, undated studio canvas now called Mountain Majesty (collection of Jon and Barbara Landau), which, as William Hauptman has shown, is premised on the Lauterbrunnen Valley, raise new questions as they resolve old ones.4 Other small oils by Bierstadt of similar subjects in both the Alps and the Rockies shed little light on this problem.5 To add that The Snow Mountain resembles the taller of the two cloud-borne crests in Bierstadt's Storm in the Rocky Mountains, Mount Rosalie (1866, The Brooklyn Museum, New York), based on sketches made in 1863, is also inferentially to resurrect his verbal analogy of 1859 between the Colorado Rockies and the Bernese Alps.6 For now, the most that can be said of The Snow Mountain is that it probably dates from either the early or late 1860s.
The smaller The Coming Storm is another matter. Handed down through his first wife's heirs and bearing a date as well as a signature, it reads as a studio concoction of modest personal delight. Thematically it descends from a sequence of Bierstadt's studio canvases of the Far West culminating in the vast Among the Sierra Nevada Mountains, California (1868, National Museum of American Art, Washington, D.C.), painted in Rome, and it anticipates several larger Western landscapes by him of the 1870s in which deer are the sole denizens.7 Here, the weight of the composition, shorn of snow-capped peaks and displaying minimal rocky ridges, is carried by the writhing trees and the turbulent clouds. As in his larger, nearly contemporaneous Buffalo Trail: The Impending Storm (1869, Corcoran Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C.) , in which prairie animals also accessorize the aerial drama, the darkening sky is reflected in a patch of water. Unlike that scene, however, here the water surface is becalmed, mirroring the agitation above as though transfixed. Bierstadt was abroad when Martin Johnson Heade unveiled the last of his thunderstorm paintings—Thunderstorm on Narragansett Bay (1868, Amon Carter Museum, Fort Worth, Texas)-at the Brooklyn Art Association in March 1868,8 but he surely knew of Heade's works in this genre.
Gerald L. Carr, Addison Gallery of American Art: 65 Years, A Selective Catalogue (Andover, Massachusetts: Addison Gallery of American Art, 1996), pp. 329-30
1. New York Journal of Commerce, 14 April 1863, p.2.
2. The principal modern studies of Bierstadt are Gordon Hendricks, Albert Bierstadt: Painter of the American West (New York: Harry N. Abrams and the Amon Carter Museum of Western Art, 1974); and Nancy K. Anderson and Linda S. Ferber, Albert Bierstadt: Art & Enterprise (New York: Hudson Hills Press and The Brooklyn Museum, 1991).
3. Quoted in Hendricks, pp. 124, 126, 128; Anderson and Ferber, p. 89.
4. The Bierstadt scholar Vern Pascal (letter of 8 June 1975, Addison Gallery Archives) has proposed that The Snow Mountain depicts the Jungfrau. That Bierstadt knew the Jungfrau is confirmed by his having exhibited a painting of the subject in 1858 in his adoptive home town of New Bedford, Massachusetts; his work entitled Jungfrau at Sunset was sold at H. H. Leeds, New York, on 25 March 1864. William Hauptman (La Suisse sublime vue par les peintres voyageurs, 1770-1914 [Lugano and Geneva: Fondation Thyssen-Bornemisza and Musee d'art et d'histoire, 1991], p. 182) insightfully compares Majesty of the Mountains to a view of Lauterbrunnen by Sanford R. Gifford; the snow peaks visible in the actual scene evidently do not comprise the Jungfrau. But Hauptman's proposed identification of that Bierstadt painting with one shown in New Bedford in 1857 is unlikely, in this writer's opinion. That Majesty of the Mountains, stylistically as well as thematically an embodiment of much of the painter's mature oeuvre, is undated all but removes it from his formative years. More probably Bierstadt returned artistically to a site of his prior Swiss travels after revisiting the country in 1868.
5. Cf. two oil studies of dimensions similar to the present work in the Whitney Gallery of Western Art, Buffalo Bill Historical Center, Cody, Wyoming (ill., Hendricks, CL-271, CL-272); two in the National Cowboy Hall of Fame, Oklahoma City (ill., Hendricks, CL-220, CL-225); one in the Colorado Springs Fine Art Center, Colorado Springs (ill., Hendricks, CL-36); and one in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston (ill., Hendricks, p. 252). Cf. also Snow Covered Mountain in the Mist (ill., Matthew Baigell, Oil Sketches by Albert Bierstadt, 1830-1902 [New York: Davis & Langdale, 1982], no. I); and the 22-by-30-inch painting entitled Lake Silva Plat near St. Moritz (with Vose Galleries of Boston in 1968).
6. Bierstadt's statement appeared in one of his letters to The Crayon (New York), September 1859, p. 287; quoted in Hendricks, p. 70; Anderson and Ferber, p. 72. Cf. also, e.g., the 361/2 -by-261/4-inch painting called Lander's Peak (?), Wyoming (Sotheby Parke Bernet, Los Angeles, 7-9 November 1979, no. 302).
7. Bierstadt's 33-by-47-inch canvas, dated 1866, and now called Rocky Mountains (formerly IBM International Foundation, New York; Sotheby's, New York, 25 May 1995, no. 184) is an instructive medium-size ancestor of Among the Sierra Nevada Mountains, California. Rocky Mountains, an ambitious work about which little is known despite its extensive exhibition resume since World War II, presumably was not the painting "of considerable size" (Utica Morning Herald and Daily Gazette, 1 February 1866, p. 2) shown at the Utica, New York, Art Association in February 1866, under the nonpreemptive title Among the Sierra Nevada Mountains (no. 38). In any event the lower right portion of the fanciful Rocky Mountains loosely anticipates the present painting. Among Bierstadt paintings of the 1870s, cf., e.g., Hetch Hetchie Canyon, Mount Holyoke College Art Museum, South Hadley, Massachusetts; King's River Canyon (ill., The Artist as Explorer [New York: Hirschl & Adler Galleries, 1992]); Landscape on the Platte River, Columbus Museum of Art, Ohio (ill., Hendricks, CL-188); Mountain Lake, The Museum of Fine Arts, Houston (ill., Hendricks, CL-239); Evening on Oneida Lake, Haggin Museum, Stockton, California (ill., Hendricks, CL-29).
8. On this painting and its relatives, see Sarah Cash, Ominous Hush: The Thunderstorm Paintings of Martin Johnson Heade (Fort Worth, Texas: Amon Carter Museum, 1994).
This object was included in the following exhibitions:
- The Hudson River School and the Early American Landscape Tradition The Art Institute of Chicago , 2/15/1945 - 5/18/1945
- Exhibition of Works from the Addison Gallery Northfield School for Girls , 10/31/1953 - 11/22/1953
- Loan exhibition of American Paintings Topsfield Public Library , 5/15/1955 - 6/15/1955
- Artistic Highlights of American History Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/10/1958 - 3/23/1958
- Major Works in Minor Scale American Federation of Arts , 12/4/1959 - 12/22/1960
- The Hudson River School American Federation of Arts , 12/1/1960 - 3/1/1962
- Albert Bierstadt Santa Barbara Museum of Art , 8/4/1964 - 9/13/1964
- A Century of American Art, 1866-1966 : 100 years of visual evolution University Art Galleries, University of New Hampshire , 1/15/1966 - 2/15/1966
- Albert Bierstadt Amon Carter Museum of American Art , 1/27/1972 - 1/3/1973
- Visions of the New Land: 19th Century American Landscape Addison Gallery of American Art , 11/7/1980 - 12/7/1980
- Masterworks of American Art from the Addison Gallery Collection Hirschl and Adler Galleries, Inc. , 10/6/1981 - 10/31/1981
- Images of the land : 200 years of landscape painting in Northeastern America Heritage Plantation of Sandwich , 5/1/1983 - 10/20/1983
- American Masterworks Addison Gallery of American Art , 10/5/1990 - 12/16/1990
- Point of View: Landscapes from the Addison Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 10/16/1992 - 12/20/1992
- Masterworks from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/21/1994 - 4/3/1994
- Addison Gallery of American Art: 65 Years Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/13/1996 - 7/31/1996
- Framing America's Landscapes: Painting from the Addison Gallery of American Art Addison Gallery of American Art , 11/20/1998 - 7/31/1999
- Masterworks from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 2/22/2000 - 3/26/2000
- Landscapes from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/28/2000 - 7/31/2000
- The American Land: Selections from the Addison Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/19/2001 - 4/8/2001
- Place and Perceptions Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/16/2002 - 7/31/2002
- Chance Encounters: (Un)Selected Works from the Addison Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/2/2003 - 11/30/2003
- Tracing the Sublime Addison Gallery of American Art , 12/16/2003 - 3/21/2004
- Eye on the Collection: Copley to Hopper Addison Gallery of American Art , 12/21/2004 - 6/12/2005
- Eye on the Collection: West to Hopper Addison Gallery of American Art , 6/17/2005 - 10/16/2005
- The Small Format Landscape Addison Gallery of American Art , 12/23/2005 - 4/9/2006
- Coming of Age: American Art, 1850s to 1950s American Federation of Arts , 9/9/2006 - 9/7/2009
- Inside, Outside, Upstairs, Downstairs: The Addison Anew Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/7/2010 - 3/27/2011
- 80 @ 80 Addison Gallery of American Art , 10/15/2011 - 12/31/2011
- Eye on the Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/19/2013 - 3/10/2013
- Natural Selections Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/14/2013 - 3/16/2014
- [Permanent Collection 201-5] Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/12/2014 - 7/31/2014
- Exterior Spaces, Interior Places Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/2/2014 - 1/4/2015
- Heaven and Earth Addison Gallery of American Art , 2/7/2015 - 4/5/2015
- Selections from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/12/2015 - 3/13/2016
- Selections from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/30/2016 - 7/31/2016
- Eye on the Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/1/2016 - 3/19/2017
- Eye on the Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/1/2017 - 7/30/2017
- Eye on the Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/1/2017 - 7/31/2018
- In and Out of Place Addison Gallery of American Art , 2/16/2019 - 7/31/2019
- A Wildness Distant from Ourselves: Art and Ecology in Nineteenth-Century America Addison Gallery of American Art , 9/1/2019 - 7/31/2020
- Learning to Look: The Addison at 90 Addison Gallery of American Art , 5/8/2021 - 2/6/2022
- Regarding America: 19th Century Art from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/23/2022 - 7/31/2022
This object has the following bibliographic references:
- tests of Andover Inn reproductions . Palm Press, Inc.. 2010
- Steven J. Ross. Winslow Homer: Society and Solitude . University of Memphis. 1/2007
This object is a member of the following portfolios:
Exhibitions: A Wildness Distant from Ourselves: Art and Ecology in Nineteenth-Century America
Exhibitions: In and Out of Place
Exhibitions: Learning to Look: The Addison at 90
Exhibitions: Regarding America: 19th Century Art from the Permanent Collection
Periods and Styles: The Hudson River School
Themes: Flora and Fauna
Themes: MLC Portfolio: Representing the Land
Your current search criteria is: Exhibition is "Albert Bierstadt".