Office Board for Smith Brothers Coal Company1879
28 1/4 in. x 24 in. (71.76 cm x 60.96 cm)
Peto painted rack pictures during two distinct phases of his career.2 The first occurred during the years 1879-85, the period to which the Addison’s example belongs; the second ran from 1894 to 1907. In the earlier period, he created rack pictures which, like the Addison’s, make specific references to places of business. Compositionally, they tend to be more crowded and complicated than those of the later period, and, more often than not, they include objects apparently unrelated to each other—photographs, almanacs, keys, and pieces of string, for instance. A larger number of tapes are shown in the earlier paintings; the Addison’s still life has ten tapes set within a frame of four more, which is about as many as Peto ever used. There are fewer tapes in the later pictures, often only two forming a simple “X” within a frame of four others.
In Office Board for Smith Brothers Coal Company, the tapes hold an almanac dated 1879, a “dinner check,” a greeting card with a floral border, an annual report for some unidentifiable business, two letters (on one envelope, the name Smith can be made out), a postcard addressed to the artist, the illustrated business card of the Smith Brothers Coal Company from which the painting takes its title, a calling card from one “Dr. H. Jones,” a postcard depicting flowers and a hovering bee, and an envelope with the cryptic phrase: IMPORTANT INFORMATION INSIDE. A number of these elements appear in other rack pictures by Peto. For example, the greeting card is seen in Rack Picture with Telegraph, Letter, and Postcards (1880, New York art market, 1983) and in Office Board for Christian Faser (1880, collection of Jo Ann and Julian Ganz, Jr., Los Angeles), which also uses the envelope inscribed IMPORTANT INFORMATION INSIDE.3 Even the card for the Smith Brothers Coal Company reappears in the latter painting, but with the name Benson replacing that of Smith.
The recurrence of certain objects in different rack pictures—and especially the fact that the name on the Smiths’ business card here could be so readily changed to Benson in Office Board for Christian Faser—suggests that these still lifes were not necessarily commissioned by the individuals or companies who happen to be referred to in them, and that the objects depicted did not necessarily have any particular or specific meaning for patrons. That is, there is no evidence that a company owned by brothers named Smith commissioned or ever owned the Addison's painting; in fact, attempts to identify the company have been unsuccessful, and it seems likely that it was a product of Peto’s imagination. It seems equally likely that most or all of the objects depicted in this and similar paintings were actually owned by Peto, not by his patrons.4 To be sure, Peto may have included certain items in order to encourage potential patrons to buy a picture; but, again, there is no evidence that such a lure, if indeed it existed, had the desired effect.5
Although Peto is now among the best-known American still-life painters of the nineteenth century, his fame was limited during his own lifetime. In fact, his reputation has since suffered by comparison with that of his better-appreciated contemporary William Michael Harnett, who was generally thought to have influenced Peto in almost everything that Peto did. The scholarship of art historians Alfred Frankenstein and, more recently, John Wilmerding has done much to clear up the confusion surrounding the two artists, and it has even been suggested that, while Harnett certainly influenced Peto, Peto may have had some influence on Harnett, too.6 In fact, it is Peto’s Office Board for Smith Brothers Coal Company which specifically suggests that this may have been the case. Surely it cannot be coincidental that both Peto and Harnett created their first rack pictures in the same year, 1879. An envelope in Harnett’s painting (The Artist’s Letter Rack, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York) is dated 26 August 1879, and most scholars have assumed this to mean that Harnett actually painted the image in that month and year. If so—and this dating of the painting has recently been questioned7—then Peto’s Office Board for Smith Brothers Coal Company, which is dated June 1879, was painted first, indicating that it was Peto who inspired Harnett to take up the genre of rack pictures instead of the other way around.
David B. Dearinger, Addison Gallery of American Art: 65 Years, A Selective Catalogue (Andover, Massachusetts: Addison Gallery of American Art, 1996), pp. 444-45; revised by Kelley Tialiou, Charles H. Sawyer Curatorial Assistant | Librarian | Archivist
1. Alfred Frankenstein, “Harnett, Peto, Haberle,” Artforum 4 (October 1965), p. 31. Peto probably painted dozens of rack pictures, while the other major American still-life painter of the day, William Michael Harnett, painted only two. It is also interesting to note that when Peto painted a full-length portrait of himself in 1904 (Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art; illustrated in John Wilmerding, Important Information Inside: The Art of John F. Peto and the Idea of Still-Life Painting in Nineteenth-Century America [Washington, D.C.: National Gallery of Art, 1983], p. 229), he depicted himself working on a large rack picture which dominates the background and which can be identified as his A Closet Door (1904-06, Amon Carter Museum of American Art).
2. This division was first noted by Alfred Frankenstein in After the Hunt: William Harnett and Other American Still Life Painters, 1870-1900 (1953; rev. ed., Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1969), pp. 51, 108; repeated by William H. Gerdts and Russell Burke in American Still-Life Painting (New York, Washington, and London: Praeger Publishers, 1971), p. 144; and by Wilmerding, p. 208.
3. Among Peto’s other rack pictures are The Rack (1880, Arizona State University, Tempe), Old Souvenirs (1881, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York), Rack Picture for William Malcolm Bunn (1882, National Museum of American Art, Washington, D.C.), Office Board (1885, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York), Old Time Letter Rack (1894, The Museum of Modern Art, New York), Old Time Letter Rack (1894, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston), and Card Rack with Jack of Hearts (c. 1900, The Cleveland Museum of Art).
4. Many of the objects which appear in Peto’s still lifes were catalogued by Alfred Frankenstein in the late 1940s when he discovered them in Peto’s former home and studio in Island Heights, New Jersey. Frankenstein’s inventory of these objects is part of his "Report from Island Heights" (Alfred Frankenstein Papers, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C., microfilm reel 1377).
5. These points are discussed in Doreen Bolger’s article, "The Early Rack Paintings of John F. Peto: 'Beneath the Nose of the Whole World,'" to be published in the Princeton University Press book, The Object as Subject: Essays on the Interpretation of Still Life, ed. Ann W. Lowenthal. Bolger also suggests that Peto may have altered already finished pictures in order to suit clients’ needs or tastes and in order to include direct references to them. She posits that Office Board for Smith Brothers Coal Company was simply a demonstration piece, executed to make clients aware of the artist's talents. The use of the name Smith was possibly a stand-in, then, for whatever name a client might wish to have inserted in its place. I wish to thank Doreen Bolger for sharing a manuscript version of this article prior to its publication.
6. See especially Frankenstein, After the Hunt; and Wilmerding.
7. Bolger, n. 29.
This object was included in the following exhibitions:
- Twenty American Paintings Addison Gallery of American Art , 2/1/1956 - 2/28/1956
- 25th Anniversary Gifts Addison Gallery of American Art , 6/1/1957 - 6/30/1957
- Pop Art and the American Tradition Milwaukee Art Museum , 4/9/1965 - 5/9/1965
- Selections from the Addison Gallery of American Art William Crapo Gallery , 10/27/1965 - 11/23/1965
- The American Still Life 1879-1979 Addison Gallery of American Art , 10/26/1979 - 12/12/1979
- Masterworks of American Art from the Addison Gallery Collection Hirschl and Adler Galleries, Inc. , 10/6/1981 - 10/31/1981
- Important Information Inside: The Art of John F. Peto and the Idea of Still-Lif National Gallery of Art , 1/16/1983 - 9/18/1983
- Bilder us der Neuen Welt - Amerikanische Malerie des 18. und 19. Jahrhunderts Staatliche Museen Preussischer Kultubesitz Berlin , 11/21/1988 - 5/15/1989
- American Masterworks Addison Gallery of American Art , 10/5/1990 - 12/16/1990
- Addison Gallery of American Art: 65 Years Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/13/1996 - 7/31/1996
- Focus On: The Permanent Collection The Hyde Collection , 10/18/1996 - 12/1/1996
- Framework: American Pictures and Frames Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/16/1999 - 4/4/1999
- Jonathan Seliger: Floor Model The Tang Teaching Museum and Art Gallery at Skidmore College , 6/16/2001 - 8/26/2001
- Defying Distinction: Works from the Addison Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/12/2002 - 4/14/2002
- Deceptions and Illusions: Five Centuries of Trompe l'oeil Painting National Gallery of Art , 10/13/2002 - 3/2/2003
- Eye on the Collection: Copley to Hopper Addison Gallery of American Art , 12/21/2004 - 6/12/2005
- Eye on the Collection: West to Hopper Addison Gallery of American Art , 6/17/2005 - 10/16/2005
- Toward Abstraction Addison Gallery of American Art , 12/23/2005 - 3/26/2006
- Coming of Age: American Art, 1850s to 1950s American Federation of Arts , 9/9/2006 - 9/7/2009
- Mix and Match: A Conversation between Paintings and Works on Paper Addison Gallery of American Art , 1/23/2007 - 4/8/2007
- So Long, Farewell Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/7/2007 - 7/31/2007
- Eye on the Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/27/2013 - 7/31/2013
- Peindre l'Amérique. Les artistes du Nouveau Monde (1830-1900) Fondation de l'Hermitage , 6/27/2014 - 10/26/2014
- Searching for the Real Addison Gallery of American Art , 5/30/2015 - 7/31/2015
- Eye on the Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/1/2017 - 7/30/2017
- Man Up! Visualizing Masculinity in 19th-Century America Addison Gallery of American Art , 12/21/2019 - 4/5/2020
- Currents/Crosscurrents: American Art, 1850–1950 Addison Gallery of American Art , 10/16/2020 - 3/7/2021
- Regarding America: 19th Century Art from the Permanent Collection Addison Gallery of American Art , 4/23/2022 - 7/31/2022
This object has the following bibliographic references:
- William Hauptman. Peindre l'Amérique. Les artistes du Nouveau Monde. 1830-1900 . La Bibliothèque des Arts, Lausanne. 6/2014
- merchandise associated with Coming of Age exhibition . Dulwich Picture Gallery.
- press for Coming of Age: American Art, 1850s to 1950s . American Federation of Arts.
- The World of William Glackens: The C. Richard Hilker Lectures, Volume II . Sansom Foundation. April 2017
- Emerson’s Memory Loss . Oxford University Press. 2018
This object is a member of the following portfolios:
Your current search criteria is: Portfolio is "Collection Highlights".